The disciplinary procedures of Southern Arkansas University, as are all activities on the University campus, are designed to be a part of the teaching process and normally cover a wide spectrum of disciplinary measures which may range from counseling to dismissal.
Southern Arkansas University recognizes the basic rights of the individual, and provides guarantees to the students, which grow out of the fundamental conception of fairness implicit in procedural due process.
In order to protect the educational process of the University and at the same time to protect the rights of all students, the University has authority to develop and enforce regulations and to impose disciplinary penalties on students found guilty of offenses or violations of rules and regulations. The process for enforcement of University rules and regulations for student conduct shall conform to the procedures stated below. However, residence hall and apartment rules and motor vehicle regulations and procedures under which the University applies to collect monies, continue in force, and adjudication of questions arising under them need not comply with the following procedures when controversies are amenable to these procedures. Violations of University Housing regulations may be handled through the University Housing resident directors, director of University Housing, and/or referred to the dean of students for disciplinary procedures.
The appointed staff through the Office of Student Life is charged with the responsibility of initiating student disciplinary procedures and meeting with the student. In the process of meeting and counselling with the student, which may sometimes comprise two or more interview appointments, a determination of responsibility will be made, or the student affairs staff may request a hearing before the University Discipline Committee in the event of severe discipline. The determination of responsibility shall be made on the basis of whether it is more likely than not that the accused student violated University regulations.
All charges and possible disciplinary actions shall be presented to the accused student in written form sent or delivered to the student’s University e-mail address. This shall constitute full and adequate notice. However, the University reserves the right to use other reasonable means to notify students. This includes, but is not limited to, the use of the student’s University mailing address. The failure of a student to check his or her University e-mail account, provide an address change or forwarding address, or the refusal or inability to accept the electronic or mailed notice, shall not constitute good cause for failure to comply with the notification.
The student will be informed by written or electronic notice of the finding of responsibility and recommended action. Except when a hearing already has been requested by the student affairs staff, the notice shall offer student the choice of either abiding by the recommended action or requesting a hearing before the University Discipline Committee. The student’s choice shall be made in writing and delivered to the dean of students on or before the date specified in the notice that proposed the action. If no written notice of choice is received within the time specified, the action proposed and the procedure shall be considered final.
The staff member and the student may choose a less formal procedure by agreeing on the specific charges and the nature of the evidence upon which the recommended actions are based. The student will be informed of his procedural rights, including the right to a hearing and appeal. When there is agreement between the student and the staff member, the procedure shall be considered final.
The disciplinary actions the University may take include, but are not limited to, the following:
- Expulsion: separation of the student from the University; the student is not eligible for readmission to the University.
- Dismissal: separation of the student from the University for an indefinite period of time.
- Suspension: separation of the student from the University for a definite period of time.
- Disciplinary probation: official warning that the student’s conduct is 1) in violation of the rules, requests, and policies stated in SAU publications, official correspondence, or announcement; or 2) in violation of Arkansas or federal criminal statutes. Disciplinary probation will be imposed for varying periods of time when a student enrolls following a period of disciplinary suspension, dismissal, or expulsion. Disciplinary probation can be imposed for varying periods of time and can include the following:
1. ineligibility to hold office in the University.
2. ineligibility to represent the University in any official function.
3. ineligibility to continue to receive a University-sponsored scholarship, grant, work and/or loan.
4. placing an informational notice in the student’s permanent file.
5. continued enrollment depends upon the maintenance of satisfactory conduct throughout the period of probation.
- Letter of enrollment block: a letter stating that the student may not reenter SAU without prior approval through the Office of Student Life if enrollment has been blocked for a previous disciplinary problem or for medical reasons.
- Letter of reprimand: a written admonition of a student for actions unbecoming to the University community.
- Loss of campus housing privileges: removed from University housing for disciplinary reasons.
- Community Service Hours: Hours the student may be required to volunteer with an approved campus or community agency/department.
- Work hours: hours that a student may be required to work in a specified area of service to the University.
- Restrictions: the withdrawal of specified privileges for a definite period of time.
- Restitution: the withdrawal of specified privileges for a definite period of time.
- Monetary fines: a fine assessed by the University which is placed on the sanctioned student’s account.
- Educational sanctions: All consequences of the student judicial process are intended to be educational. In this context, however, the term –educational sanctions specifically describe those tasks, assignments, or experiences that a student is obligated to complete as a result of the Discipline Committee or staff’s decision. Educational sanctions may be imposed in combination with or as a condition of any other disciplinary sanction. Educational sanctions may, for example, require the student to prepare letters of apology, to research an issue related to the offense, to attend a workshop, lecture, or meeting, or to attend counseling.
Mandatory Leave of Absence
In certain circumstances, the dean of students may impose a University or residence hall leave of absence prior to the hearing before a judicial body. The leave of absence shall become immediately effective without prior notice.
Interim suspension may be imposed only:
- a) To ensure the safety and will being of members of the University community or preservation of University property;
- b) If the student poses a definite threat of disruption of or interference with the normal operations of the University.
During the interim suspension, students shall be denied access to University housing and/or to the campus (including classes) and/or all other University activities or privileges for which the student might otherwise be eligible, as the dean of students may determine to be appropriate. A leave of absence may be appealed to the Vice President of Student Affairs.
2.5.1 Discipline Committee Hearing
The circumstance, which results in a hearing before the University Discipline Committee, is the referral by the student affairs staff of a situation involving disciplinary action upon the request of the student involved or the student affairs staff.
Points involved in such hearings traditionally have been classified as:
- (1) issues of fact (did a certain incident occur? Was the student involved in the incident?),
- (2) issues related to the nature or character of the incident (Was it an accidental, careless, or intentional action? Was it spontaneous, or premeditated? Were there justifiable reasons or extenuating circumstances?),
- (3) issues of degree or extent (Was it minor, moderate, or major?),
- (4) issues of jurisdiction (Does the administration have jurisdiction over the incident and the persons involved?).
The purpose of the hearing is to allow the committee to judge whether a violation of regulations of student conduct has occurred and to recommend the appropriate action to be taken. The hearing procedure is an effort by the University to provide students with institutional due process and to provide an atmosphere in which students can both learn and practice rules and procedures of responsible social conduct. The University further seeks to apply in actual practice those principles and rules of justice and civic responsibility incubated by its faculty in academic process.
When a hearing is requested, the dean of students shall make arrangements for the hearing and shall notify the student of the time, date, and place of the hearing. Unless the student requests otherwise, the hearing will be closed except to participants. The student shall notify the dean of students in advance of the hearing if the student desires the hearing to be public.
At the hearing, the student is entitled to be present with a University advisor of his/her choice (Sec. 2.5.2) to testify on his or her own behalf, to present witnesses, to ask questions of witnesses who appear, and to examine all evidence presented to the committee. Attorneys are not permitted to be present or participate in the student discipline process unless the student is also facing criminal prosecution regarding the incident for which the hearing is being held or the student has been suspended from the university for 10 days or more. An audio recording shall be made of the hearing and shall be kept by the dean of students for one year. The chairperson of the University Discipline Committee shall preside over the hearing and shall rule on the admissibility of evidence, which may include hearsay, and on all other questions regarding the conduct of the hearing.
The appropriate hearing procedure is for the Office of Student Life designee to present a narration of the facts in the situation and specify any action they have recommended. The student then specifies the precise point at issue (the issue of fact, character, extent, or jurisdiction which occasions this hearing).
After the point at issue is specified, the student affairs staff, assuming the burden of proof, presents its position. It may present whatever relevant evidence testimony, explanation, or argument it feels appropriate. After presentation of the student affairs’ position, the student may present whatever relevant evidence, testimony, explanation, or argument the student feels appropriate.
Members of the discipline committee may ask questions to clarify issues a whatever point they feel necessary; however, such questions should not interrupt a speaker during the presentation unless the questions are essential. All participants may ask questions after the initial presentations are made.
After all relevant matters have been placed before the committee, it shall deliberate in closed session and render a decision. In the decision, the committee may:
- affirm the original finding and sanction;
- affirm the original finding, but lessen the sanction;
- affirm the original finding and increase the sanction; or
- reverse the original finding.
The chairperson of the committee shall forward to the dean of students a written report of the decision and the reasons thereof. The Office of Student Life will report the decision of the hearing committee in a letter to the student and inform him or her of the right to appeal to the president of the university on or before a specified date. If no written notice of appeal is received within the time specified and the Office of the President does not choose to review the proceedings, the action proposed shall be imposed and the disposition shall be considered final.
An ad hoc hearing board may be established by the president whenever the University Discipline Committee is not constituted, is unable to obtain a quorum, or is otherwise unable to hear a case. An ad hoc hearing board shall be composed of three members, including at least one student.
Appeal of the decision of the University Discipline Committee may be made in writing to the to the president of the university before the stated deadline. The appeal must state the grounds for believing the decision to be erroneous or unfair. An appeal of the disciplinary decision may be made only on justifiable grounds, including irregularity in proceedings, punishment inconsistent with the nature of the offenses, additional pertinent evidence not available for the original hearing, or a question of fact. The president may deny a request for an appeal if the student fails to show sufficient grounds for an appeal.
If sufficient grounds for the appeal are met, both parties may present additional evidence or other objections, not presented in previous proceedings, upon which the appeal is based in writing to the president of the university. Following these presentations, the president will review the previous proceedings along with the additional evidence or objections. The president will then determine whether the disciplinary rights have been properly observed. In the decision, the president may:
- affirm the decision of the discipline committee, which shall be effective as of the date specified by the committee;
- affirm the decision of the discipline committee and reduce the sanction, which shall be effective as of the date specified b the discipline committee;
- affirm the decision of the discipline committee and increase the sanction, which shall be effective as of the date specified by the discipline committee;
- reverse the decision against the student;
- reverse the decision against the student and order a new hearing by the discipline committee.
The president will notify the student and proceed appropriately.
2.5.2 Role of the University Advisor in Disciplinary Hearings
Service as a University advisor on behalf of a student appearing before the University Discipline Committee does not imply the presumption of either guilt or innocence of the student by the faculty member serving in such capacity. Such service merely recognizes the right of the student to have present with him during a period of potential emotional stress and mental anguish a person not under such pressures who may give him counsel or encouragement on matters either substantive or procedural and who may assist in the student’s defense if requested by the student. The University advisor bears no responsibility for assuming the initiative in the student’s defense.
When a faculty member serves as an advisor for a student appearing before the University Discipline Committee, no advance notice to the committee is necessary. However, both the student and the University advisor are welcome to discuss the committee procedures with he dean of students and/or the University Discipline Committee chair in advance of the hearing. Attorneys are not permitted to be present or participate in the student discipline process unless the student is also facing criminal prosecution regarding the incident for which the hearing is being held or the student is suspended for 10 days or more. Only the student, his or her University faculty advisor, and the student’s witnesses are permitted to make presentations to the University Discipline Committee.
2.5.3 Serious Violations
Arkansas Act 470 makes specific provisions in cases that may lead to expulsion or suspension. In addition to existing student conduct procedures, a student or student organization facing a “serious violation” charge is entitled to the following:
- The right to receive a copy of Arkansas Act 470 at the inception of the disciplinary matter.
- The right to be represented by an attorney or non-attorney advocate. The University shall not be responsible for providing, training, or paying for the services of an attorney or a non-attorney advocate.
- The right to have the opportunity for a live hearing. Should a student or student organization waive the right to be present at a disciplinary proceeding, the student or student organization must submit a waiver signed by the student or student organization and the adjudicator of the administrative proceeding. If a student or student organization waives the right to be present at a disciplinary proceeding, the student or student organization shall not have a right to appeal the University’s initial decision.
- The right to an appeal to be filed within 25 days after a student or student organization receives final notice of the University’s decision.
- At the conclusion of a disciplinary proceeding or an appeal that involves a serious violation, the University vice-president of student affairs shall certify that the substantial rights of student complainants and respondents as established under Arkansas Act 470 have been followed.
2.5.4 Failure to Appear
If a student notified to appear before University administration, staff, or the discipline committee fails to comply, and staff or the chairperson of the discipline committee, as the case may be, reasonably believes the failure to be inexcusable; the staff member or discipline committee will make a decision on the basis of information which is available, and shall impose the sanction considered appropriate. When it appears necessary to avoid undue hardship or to avoid injustice, the dean of students may extend the time to enable a student to respond to an accusation or prepare a defense.